For years, many employers have viewed an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Form I-9 audit as something that happens to other organizations. That mindset may need to change. Federal immigration enforcement has intensified, and employers are facing increased scrutiny of their employment eligibility verification practices.
Reported ICE inspection activity has increased dramatically. Industry estimates indicate that Notices of Inspection (NOIs) issued during the first half of 2025 were at least 10 times higher than during the same period in 2024. Other reports indicate that more than 5,200 audit notices were issued to employers nationwide during 2025.
While a comprehensive official ICE count of Notices of Inspection issued in 2026 has not been publicly established, enforcement activity remains a significant concern for employers.
The increased scrutiny is accompanied by important changes to ICE's inspection and penalty procedures in 2026.
Employers across industries and of all sizes should consider whether they are prepared to respond to an inspection.
What's Changed in 2026?
ICE updated its Form I-9 inspection guidance in March 2026 and again on August 31, 2026. These changes are particularly important because certain errors that employers may previously have viewed as technical or procedural deficiencies are now classified as substantive violations.
For employers, this means that some mistakes may result in financial penalties without the opportunity to correct them during an inspection.
2026 potential financial penalties include:
- $288–$2,861 per Form I-9 for substantive verification violations and uncorrected technical or procedural violations.
- $716–$5,724 per individual for knowingly hiring or continuing to employ an unauthorized individual.
Actual penalties depend on the circumstances, applicable violation category, and statutory penalty factors. These amounts are subject to adjustment.
The August 2026 guidance also addressed electronic I-9 audit trails, warning notices, and additional procedures involving employees whose work authorization expires or is rescinded during an inspection.
These developments reinforce the importance of reviewing not only the accuracy of individual I-9 forms but also the systems and processes employers use to maintain compliance.
What Is Driving the Increased Scrutiny?
ICE's Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) division uses Notices of Inspection to formally request an employer's Forms I-9 and related employment records. These inspections are intended to identify errors in employment eligibility verification, paperwork violations, and potential unauthorized employment.
An I-9 inspection is more than a review of whether forms exist. ICE may examine whether forms were completed accurately and within the required deadlines, whether employment authorization was properly verified, and whether the organization complied with federal recordkeeping requirements.
The consequences can include substantial financial penalties, additional government scrutiny, and, in more serious cases, criminal investigations.
What Happens When an Employer Receives a Notice?
Employers generally have at least three business days to produce requested Forms I-9 and supporting documentation. ICE may also request payroll records, employee rosters, business licenses, and other employment records.
The short response window can pose significant challenges for organizations without organized, accessible records or a designated response process.
Employers should not wait until a notice arrives to determine who will coordinate the response, communicate with ICE, involve legal counsel, and gather the requested information.
How Should Employers Prepare?
With inspection activity increasing, employers should take several practical steps:
- Review I-9 compliance: Conduct periodic reviews to identify missing forms, incomplete sections, untimely completion, improper corrections, and missed reverification requirements.
- Know your retention requirements: Forms I-9 must generally be retained for three years after hire or one year after termination, whichever is later.
- Monitor work authorization: Maintain a process for tracking expiring employment authorization and completing reverification when required.
- Understand your electronic system: Ensure Forms I-9 and audit trails can be retrieved quickly and accurately.
- Establish an inspection response plan: Identify who will receive notices, coordinate records, contact legal counsel, and communicate with ICE.
- Train responsible employees: Ensure HR and hiring managers understand I-9 requirements and their responsibilities.
Don't Wait Until ICE Comes Knocking
The reported increase in Notices of Inspection is a reminder that I-9 compliance deserves ongoing attention. Employers should not assume that an inspection is unlikely simply because they have never experienced one.
A proactive approach can help organizations identify vulnerabilities, address compliance gaps, and respond more confidently if ICE comes knocking.
The question is no longer just whether your organization is I-9 compliant. It's whether you are prepared to demonstrate it when ICE asks.
If your organization needs assistance conducting an internal I-9 audit, addressing potential compliance gaps, or navigating I-9 questions, contact MRA for guidance and support to help ensure your organization is prepared and positioned for I-9 compliance.